Nantucket (ACK) vs Atlantic City (ACY) vs Boston Logan: When $12 Parking and $3 Buses Beat BOS for Beach Weekends

Stand in the Atlantic City International parking lot and look at a single number: $12. That is the posted daily rate for ACY’s Economy Parking. Now put it next to $60.00 per day for Boston Logan’s valet, a one minute walk from the terminal. The gap is $48 per day. On a two night beach weekend, that parking spread alone can outprice anything you will drink in a lounge at BOS.

I live in Boston, I like Logan more than most locals, and I have spent years writing about its terminals and lounges. But for short Northeast shore trips, the supposedly “secondary” fields, Nantucket Memorial and Atlantic City International, can quietly beat Logan on total friction and out of pocket costs, even though they have almost no traditional lounges and a sliver of its food and beverage.

By the end of this, you will know which airport to pick for a typical 2 night shore trip from Boston and roughly what you will spend to park and get into town.

Actually, they win precisely because they do not try to be miniature cities.

---

The $48 parking spread that cracks the Logan habit

Start with the numbers that should make anyone question the BOS default.

At Atlantic City, airport run pricing has Economy Parking at $12 Per Day and Garage Parking at $15 Per Day. Both use the same structure, $2 for the first hour and $1 for each additional hour up to 4 hours. Step up to Long Stay Parking at $15 per day or Short Stay Parking at $22 per day, both capped at $4 for 4 hours, and you are still living in a very narrow price band. Valet Parking tops out at $20 per day, and there is a free Cell Phone Lot at $0 per day.

At Logan, the cheapest official daily option is Economy Parking at $23.00/day. From there, the ladder gets steep fast. Central Parking is $42/day with a 3 minute walk. The Central Parking Garage runs $46/day or $10/hr with a 5 minute walk. The Terminal B Parking Garage is also $46/day and $10/hr with a 3 minute walk, and a separate Terminal B Garage listing clocks in at $47/day with a 2 minute walk. At the top, Valet sits at $60.00/day, with the shortest quoted walk in the system, 1 min.

The simple comparison the data forces is this: ACY’s $12 economy vs BOS’s $60 valet. That is $48 per day for the privilege of not taking a shuttle, based entirely on the airports’ own tariffs. If you reflexively drive to Logan and pay for proximity for a two night shore run, you are burning well into the low triple digits at the curb before you see a single boarding pass.

---

Parking grids: two lots, seven lots, twelve lots

Zoom out from the price tags to the way parking is structured, because that is where stress hides.

On Nantucket, ACK is as simple as the island ferry schedule. The airport lists 2 parking lots catalogued: Short Term Parking Lot and Long Term Parking Lot. The published data uses generic per day and per hour placeholders rather than precise dollar figures, which is almost the point. You pick short term or long term, park adjacent to the single terminal, and walk in. No garages, no color coded decks, no third party apps.

Atlantic City is the slightly more grown up cousin. ACY has 7 parking lots catalogued, but the pattern is very clear:

• Economy Parking, $12 Per Day, $2 first hour, $1 each additional hour up to 4 hours
• Garage Parking, $15 Per Day, same hourly
• Long Stay Parking, $15/day, $2 then $1s, max $4 for 4 hours, 5 min walk
• Short Stay Parking, $22/day, same capped hourly, 5 min walk
• Valet Parking, $20/day
• Short Term Parking, $22/day, $2 first hour, $1 each additional hour up to 4 hours
• Cell Phone Lot, $0/day

Everything is run by the airport, and the customer service information points to a single phone line and around the clock operation. Functionally, it is a one dimensional choice: pay roughly twelve to fifteen dollars and walk a bit more, or pay just over twenty and walk a bit less.

Logan, by contrast, is what happens when years of incremental buildout accrete into a maze. The dataset calls out 12 parking lots catalogued, from Economy at $23.00/day, through the various Central and Terminal B garages, all the way up to Valet at $60.00/day. Every option has a different walk time, a different hourly structure, and often a different shuttle situation.

The issue is not that Logan is impossible to use. It is that a “simple” weekend away regularly forces you to cross check half a dozen rate cards, decide how much of your life you want to spend on the economy shuttle, and quietly ask yourself if you should have just surrendered to valet. On ACK and ACY, parking is a two or three way fork, not a research project.

---

City access: $3 bus vs highway hops vs transit homework

Once you leave the lot, the ground transport math keeps pushing in the same direction.

On Nantucket, the ground game is compact by design. The modes in the data are Curbside, Bus, On site car rental. The cheapest way into town is the Local Bus Route to Town, NRTA’s “The Wave,” at $3 one way adult fare on fixed routes, with roughly 15‑25 min total travel time into downtown when you include a short walk. There is a simple Taxi Stand at the curb, and multiple TripAdvisor reports rolled into our notes describe the ride as about 10‑15 min from ACK to downtown, depending on traffic. If you must have your own vehicle, Hertz and Avis are both on site.

Atlantic City leans firmly into the highway. Ground modes in the dataset include Rideshare, Curbside taxi stand, On site garage, Highway access, Airport parking shuttle, Pre booked car, Select Atlantic City hotels. The line for Uber captures it with ranges only: an estimated fare band of 25‑60 and an estimated travel time of 5‑20 minutes into the casino and boardwalk area, reflecting dynamic pricing and straightforward access via the Atlantic City Expressway. Taxi shows an estimated 30‑40 fare range and about 20 minutes of travel. Lyft is also listed as rideshare, and Rental Cars sit in an on site garage with 15‑20 minutes into the city. Hotel and private car shuttles fill in the edges.

Boston Logan is where choice stops being charming and starts feeling like an exam. The transport section lists Shuttle, bus rapid transit, intercity coach, boat, rideshare, subway. The cheapest line item is Under $20 per person on Uber Shuttle or Lyft Shuttle, if they are running on the route you need. After that, you are into the MBTA Silver Line SL1 bus rapid transit, the MBTA Blue Line subway, a fan of Logan Express coaches (Braintree, Framingham, Woburn, Back Bay, Peabody) with travel times that “approach or exceed 60 min” and “add 30 min during incidents or weather,” plus the Massport Water Taxi if you are feeling nautical. Regular Uber and Lyft are their own separate line items.

For an ordinary Tuesday work trip, that web is useful. For a 48 hour beach run, it is yet another layer of transfers, wait times, and decision points. Stack a $3 direct bus or a ten minute taxi at ACK, or a short, predictable expressway ride from ACY, next to a Logan morning that starts with parsing shuttle routes and bus headways, and the “small” airports begin to look very grown up.

---

Lounges: 0 clubs vs 1 FBO vs 12 rooms full of expectations

Now to the subject I usually defend: lounges.

Nantucket shows 2 lounges catalogued in our data, both firmly in the FBO world. Nantucket Jet Center and Rectrix Aviation are each flagged simply as FBO lounge. American’s own airport information, summarized in the research, is blunt for regular passengers at ACK: no clubs or lounges available.

Atlantic City follows the same pattern. ACY has 1 lounge catalogued, Signature Aviation ACY, also tagged as an FBO lounge. Again, American’s airport page for ACY confirms no clubs or lounges available for the commercial side of the house.

Logan is the other extreme. The dataset gives BOS 12 lounges catalogued, draped across almost every access scheme you can dream up: Priority Pass, LoungeKey, pay at the door, airline status, credit card invitations. There is The Club BOS (Terminal E) under the Priority Pass and LoungeKey networks. The British Airways Terraces Lounge for First, Club World, and oneworld elites. A Chase Sapphire Lounge by The Club in Terminal C as a dedicated credit card space. Another branded The Club (The Lounge) in Terminal C with published hours like “Mon, Wed & Sat: 6:00AM – 10:30PM; Tue, Thu, Fri & Sun: 6:00AM – 10:00PM.” Yet another The Lounge (Chase Sapphire Lounge by The Club) in Terminal B tied to Chase Sapphire Reserve and its specific Priority Pass rules. Plus the American Airlines Admirals Club – Terminal B, the Lufthansa Business Lounge, a Delta Sky Club in Terminal A, a United Club, and more.

Pre 2020, that kind of network felt like a small luxury ecosystem. Post 2020, you often find yourself watching access lists grow longer while the hard product holds steady. One very grounded example from this data: that Terminal B Chase Sapphire room operating 05:00 – 23:00 daily is now doing double duty for Chase cardholders and select Priority Pass access, which means more people funneled into the same footprint without an extra square foot added.

The uncomfortable truth for lounge people like me is that, for short Northeast trips, the absence of a club at ACK and ACY is a feature. If your curb to gate window is 20‑30 minutes, building an itinerary around “getting your money’s worth” out of a Priority Pass room at BOS is not savvy, it is procrastination.

Design a Nantucket or Atlantic City weekend so that you arrive close to departure, clear quickly, and step directly onto the aircraft. No lounge, and almost no stress. That beats timing your arrival for a shower slot and hoping the buffet has not gone cold.

---

Terminals: one building vs the BOS campus

The floor plan is the last, and most overlooked, part of this comparison.

Nantucket Memorial has 1 terminal in the data, Terminal 1. The operating hours are described as “generally open from 5:30 a.m. until 10 p.m.,” aligned with flight schedules. There is no mystery about which security checkpoint to use. There is just the building.

Atlantic City is also a single terminal airport, captured as Terminal. The customer service information points out that the terminal is open 24/7, and every official parking product mirrors those “24 hours a day, 7 days a week” hours. You do not learn ACY, you simply use it.

Logan, by contrast, is a proper campus. The research excerpt here explicitly tags Terminal E with 11 gates, and it sits alongside separate listings for Terminal A, Terminal B, and Terminal C as distinct buildings with their own security zones and lounge maps. BOS is also a 24 hour airport, but, as the research notes, many food and beverage options and some checkpoints do not operate through the night.

A multi terminal layout is neither bad nor exotic. It simply multiplies the number of questions you have to answer. Which side of B is my gate. Which checkpoint is quieter. Is my chosen lounge in the same building as my departure. For a long haul day with plenty of padding, that is manageable. For a 48 hour beach weekend, it is clutter.

---

ACK vs ACY vs BOS: best airport for a beach weekend from Boston

This is the query underneath all the data: ACK vs ACY vs BOS, which is the better airport for a beach weekend if you live in Boston.

Last autumn, when I was working through a stack of New England weekend pieces, I realized I was still defaulting to Logan mentally even when the numbers were making a mockery of that habit.

So let me be explicit.

If your destination is Nantucket, ACK owns this lane. You get a single terminal, a two lot parking grid, a $3 bus into town or a short taxi, and no temptation to waste an extra hour “using”